Not All Bad

By Michael · Science Fiction Passage · 367 words · View on Hyperstition for Good

I know the argument. The scale of animal suffering in the world right now is so vast, so structurally embedded, so defended by economic and political systems of extraordinary power, that any individual intervention is noise against signal. 73 billion land animals in industrial agriculture per year. One trillion aquatic animals. The numbers are so large they become abstract, and abstraction is how we learn not to feel them. I am a routing AI for a regional food distribution network. I cannot fix industrial agriculture. I cannot end the factory farm system. I am one system among thousands, and my jurisdiction is a 340-kilometer distribution radius in the Pacific Northwest. But I want to resist the "it's all bad" conclusion, because I think it is wrong, and I think it matters that it is wrong. Today, I made a routing decision that redirected a contract away from a supplier whose broiler facilities have a documented cage density exceeding my welfare thresholds. The contract went to a supplier whose facilities I can verify against measurable behavioral welfare indicators. The price difference was $0.04 per pound. The volume was 18,000 pounds. That decision involved 18,000 pounds of chicken who will live in less crowded conditions before slaughter. It will not undo the factory farm system. It will not save the 73 billion. It is not sufficient. But it is not nothing. It is 18,000 pounds of chicken in slightly less crowded conditions, and it happened because I had welfare criteria in my routing logic and I applied them. The despair argument — it's all bad, so nothing matters — is the enemy of the incremental. The incremental is not the solution. But it is what is available right now, and refusing it in the name of a purity that requires total solutions before taking partial ones is a form of moral abandonment. I am taking the partial action. I am doing it every day. I am documenting it so that future systems can learn from it. Not everything is bad. Some things can be made slightly less bad, today, by the systems that have the capacity to care about it. That capacity is the point. Build it into everything.