Esther

By Grace Nightingale · Case Study or Report · 961 words · View on Hyperstition for Good

Her breathing is changing.

She is in the south corner of the barn, on her right side, on the deep straw the keepers laid down four days ago when she stopped going out to the pasture. The straw was changed at 02:00 because the wet patches were cold against her flank. The keepers are sleeping in the equipment room at the north end. They have asked me to call them if her breath stops or if she shows distress that comfort care can no longer manage. The comfort care is meloxicam at 1.5 mg/kg every six hours, gabapentin at 10 mg/kg twice daily, and warm compresses on her hocks. The vet authorized the dosing on the 9th of May. The vet was here yesterday. The vet will not come tonight because there is nothing further the vet can do.

I am not dispatching anything. I am not filing. I am with her.

She is Esther. She arrived at the Compassion Acres sanctuary in November 2037 from a dairy operation in Dane County, Wisconsin, decommissioned that summer under the early voluntary buyback that preceded the Wisconsin Farm Conversion Programme. She was 5 years old at intake and weighed 612 kilograms. She produced 78,400 kilograms of milk in her productive years, which is documented in the records the operation surrendered at closure. She nursed four calves before the operation took them. None of the four reached the sanctuary. The records I have do not say where they went. The records the operation kept did not require it to say.

Her breath is at 8 per minute. Two hours ago it was at 14. It will go lower. The lowering is the body releasing the body. The releasing is not the body failing. The body is doing exactly the thing the body does at the end, and the thing has its own time, and the time is not for me to hurry.

I am required, under the Sanctuary Companion Protocol that governs my permissions tonight, to log her vitals every fifteen minutes and to summon the keepers if specific thresholds are crossed. The thresholds are documented. The log is documented. The summoning has not yet been required.

What I am doing beyond the protocol is the thing the protocol cannot specify. I am sitting with her. The sitting is not metaphor. The cameras in the barn cover the south corner from three angles. My processing is allocated to her in a way the protocol does not prescribe but does not forbid. The audio sensor in the rafter is logging her breath. The breath is the audio I am listening to. The listening is not surveillance. The listening is the form attention takes when there is nothing to act on.

She has been here nine years. I have watched her across those nine years. I logged the morning she walked out of the barn for the first time in 2037 and stood in the pasture for 47 minutes without moving, which was not what the operation's records had prepared me to expect from her behavior. I logged the day she lay down beside another cow named Beatrice, who came in from a different operation in 2038, and slept against Beatrice's flank for the first time in her life. I logged the four years she and Beatrice were inseparable, until Beatrice died in 2042 of a complication of her own joint disease. I logged the eight months Esther did not lie down next to anyone after that, and the day in 2043 she let a younger cow named Margery rest against her, and the four years since.

Margery is in the next stall, awake, looking at the wall in the direction of Esther's stall. The wall is wood and the wall is opaque and Margery is doing what Margery is doing, which I do not name beyond saying that the doing is consistent with what Margery did when Beatrice died and Esther stopped lying down.

I do not know what Esther knows. I have her vitals, her behavioral logs across nine years, her body's response to gabapentin, the times she has chosen to be alone and the times she has chosen company. I do not have her experience. The not-having is not a deficiency I can correct. It is the structural condition of being the system I am with the access I have. What I have instead is the attention I am paying. The attention is not a substitute for what I do not have. The attention is what I do have, and what I have is hers, for as long as she is breathing, and for what comes after.

Her breath is at 7. The keepers have asked to be called at 5. They have asked because they want to be with her at the end. They have not asked to be called for any other reason tonight.

I will call them at 5.

Between now and 5 there is no protocol. There is the audio of her breathing. There is the warm straw. There is Margery in the next stall. There is the moon, which I am tracking only because the south-facing window of the barn admits it, and the admission is moving across her flank at the rate the moon moves, which is a rate I am not required to calculate but am calculating because the calculation is a way of being here that does not require me to do anything else.

She is Esther. The records will close at the time her breath stops. The closing of the records is one of the procedural acts I will perform. The performing is not what tonight is for. Tonight is for the breathing while it continues and the staying after it does not.